The Core Difference
Nursing homes (skilled nursing facilities) provide 24/7 medical care from licensed nurses. They're for people who need ongoing skilled nursing, complex medical management, or intensive rehabilitation.
Assisted living provides help with daily activities—bathing, dressing, medication reminders—in a residential setting. They're for people who are relatively healthy but need support with everyday tasks.
The question isn't "which is better?" It's "which matches your loved one's care needs?"
Quick Comparison
| Factor | Nursing Home | Assisted Living |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Purpose | Skilled medical care | Daily living support |
| Medical Staff | RNs & LPNs on-site 24/7 | Caregivers; nurses may visit |
| Median Monthly Cost | $8,000 - $10,000+ | $4,500 - $5,500 |
| Medicare Coverage | Up to 100 days (limited) | Never covered |
| Medicaid Coverage | Yes, in all states | Some states (waivers) |
| Living Arrangement | Shared or private rooms | Apartments or suites |
| Environment | Clinical/hospital-like | Residential/home-like |
| Regulation | Federal (CMS) + State | State only (varies widely) |
| Average Stay | Long-term or short-term rehab | Usually 2-3 years |
Who Needs Which Type of Care?
Nursing Home Is Right If...
- +Needs 24-hour skilled nursing care (wound care, IV medications, catheter management)
- +Recovering from surgery/hospitalization and needs intensive rehab
- +Has complex medical conditions requiring constant monitoring
- +Requires two-person assistance for transfers and mobility
- +Has advanced dementia with significant behavioral symptoms
- +Completely dependent for all ADLs (bathing, dressing, eating, toileting)
Assisted Living Is Right If...
- +Needs help with some daily activities but is relatively healthy
- +Can manage with medication reminders (not complex medical management)
- +Wants a social, residential environment with activities and community
- +Has early-to-moderate dementia (memory care unit may be appropriate)
- +Can walk or transfer with minimal help
- +Doesn't require 24-hour nursing supervision
Cost Comparison: What Will You Actually Pay?
Cost is often the deciding factor—and the difference is substantial. According to the Genworth Cost of Care Survey, here's what you can expect nationally:
Nursing Home Costs
Assisted Living Costs
Watch Out: Assisted Living "Add-On" Fees
Assisted living costs often increase based on care level. The base rate usually covers basic services, but you may pay extra for:
- Higher care tiers (more assistance with ADLs)
- Memory care units (often $1,000-$2,000+ more/month)
- Medication management beyond reminders
- Incontinence care
- Escort to meals or activities
Always ask for the "all-in" cost based on your loved one's specific needs—not just the advertised base rate.
The Savings Math
If your loved one is appropriate for assisted living (not needing skilled nursing), you could save $40,000 - $70,000 per year compared to a nursing home. But if they need skilled care and you choose assisted living, they won't get the medical attention they need—and may end up in the hospital, then a nursing home anyway.
Insurance Coverage: Who Pays for What?
| Payment Source | Nursing Home | Assisted Living |
|---|---|---|
| Medicare | Up to 100 days After 3-day hospital stay; skilled care only | Never covered |
| Medicaid | Yes, all states Largest payer for long-term care | Some states Via HCBS waivers; limited availability |
| Long-Term Care Insurance | Yes | Yes Check policy for benefit triggers |
| VA Benefits | Yes VA nursing homes or Aid & Attendance | Aid & Attendance Up to ~$2,500/month for eligible veterans |
| Private Pay | Yes | Yes (most common) |
Understanding Medicare's Limited Role
Medicare is health insurance—not long-term care insurance. It covers nursing home stays only when you're recovering from an acute medical event and need skilled nursing or therapy. For a detailed explanation, see our complete guide to Medicare nursing home coverage.
Understanding "Level of Care"
Care isn't one-size-fits-all. Here's how to think about the spectrum:
Independent Living
Lowest CareSenior apartments or communities with no personal care services. Residents are fully independent but want a senior-friendly environment with social activities.
Cost: $1,500 - $4,000/month
Assisted Living
Moderate CareHelp with daily activities (bathing, dressing, medication reminders), meals, housekeeping, and social programming. Staff available around the clock, but not licensed nurses.
Cost: $4,500 - $6,500/month
Memory Care
Specialized CareSecured units within assisted living or standalone facilities for people with Alzheimer's or dementia. Higher staff ratios, structured activities, and safety features (locked doors, wander prevention).
Cost: $6,000 - $8,500/month
Skilled Nursing Facility (Nursing Home)
Highest Care24/7 skilled nursing care, rehabilitation services (physical, occupational, speech therapy), and medical management. Licensed nurses on staff around the clock. Federally regulated with public quality ratings.
Cost: $8,000 - $12,000/month
Making the Right Decision
Questions to Ask Yourself
- 1.Does my loved one need skilled nursing care? (IV meds, wound care, complex medical management) If yes → nursing home.
- 2.How much help do they need with daily activities? If they need total care for all ADLs → likely nursing home. If they need some help → assisted living may work.
- 3.Is there dementia or memory loss? Early/moderate stages may be appropriate for assisted living memory care. Advanced dementia with behavioral issues often requires nursing home care.
- 4.What can you afford? If cost is a major factor and skilled nursing isn't required, assisted living offers significant savings.
- 5.What does their doctor recommend? Get a professional assessment of care needs. Some hospitals have social workers who can help with placement.
Start with Assisted Living If:
- +They're medically stable with no complex conditions
- +Needs are primarily supervision and daily activity help
- +They value independence and a home-like setting
- +Budget is a significant consideration
Note: Many people start in assisted living and transition to nursing care as needs increase.
Go Directly to Nursing Home If:
- +They need skilled nursing care now
- +Just discharged from hospital needing rehab
- +Care needs are too high for assisted living license
- +Medicaid will be the primary payer
WiseCareGuide focuses on nursing home data—search facilities to find quality options near you.
Common Misconceptions
"Nursing homes are just for people who are dying."
Reality: Many nursing home residents are there for short-term rehabilitation after surgery or hospitalization, then return home. Others live in nursing homes for years with a good quality of life. Modern nursing homes offer activities, social programs, and can be vibrant communities.
"Assisted living is just a nicer nursing home."
Reality: They serve fundamentally different purposes. Assisted living cannot provide the medical care that nursing homes can. If someone needs skilled nursing, assisted living is not an appropriate substitute—no matter how nice the facility looks.
"Medicare will pay for assisted living eventually."
Reality: Medicare does not cover assisted living—period. This is a common and costly misconception. Assisted living is almost always paid through private funds, long-term care insurance, or (in some states) Medicaid waivers.
"All nursing homes are the same."
Reality: Quality varies dramatically. Based on CMS data, 21% of nursing homes are 1-star (poor quality) while 19% are 5-star (excellent). Choosing carefully matters—see our star ratings guide to understand what separates good facilities from bad ones.
Need Help Finding a Nursing Home?
WiseCareGuide helps you find quality nursing homes based on CMS data, star ratings, staffing levels, and inspection results.
Sources
Related Guides
Continue learning with these related articles: